1968 Topps Baseball Cards: Why Mantle, Mays and Killebrew #490 Matters
1968 Topps baseball cards include a memorable three-player issue: Super Stars #490, featuring Harmon Killebrew, Willie Mays, and Mickey Mantle. It belongs to the regular 598-card set, not a separately issued insert.
- Identify: The photograph, yellow Super Stars circle, and card #490; condition and completed sales determine value.
- Compare: The trio card with the players’ individual 1968 issues.
- Decide: Whether to grade, keep, or sell it within a larger collection.
Three Different Uniforms, One Remarkable Photograph
Among 1968 Topps baseball cards, #490 stands out because Killebrew wears a Twins uniform, Mays his Giants colors, and Mantle Yankees pinstripes. One photograph brings three celebrated sluggers together.
- Not a giveaway: The card belongs in the regular 598-card Topps checklist, alongside ordinary player cards.
- Killebrew: Minnesota Twins power hitter and future American League MVP.
- Mays: Giants icon known for exceptional all-around play.
- Mantle: Yankees legend nearing the end of his playing career.
Why the Reverse Says 1,462 Home Runs
Turn over the 1968 Topps Super Stars card and Topps credits the three players with 1,462 combined major league home runs. That was a historical snapshot, not their eventual career total.
- Final totals: Willie Mays hit 660, Harmon Killebrew 573, and Mickey Mantle 536, adding up to 1,769.
- Back-of-card stories: Topps also celebrated Mays’ four-homer game, Mantle’s 1956 Triple Crown, and Killebrew’s home-run production.
- Identification clue: The reverse names all three and carries card number 490. Do not mistake the changing home-run total for a printing error.
Mantle #280, Mays #50 and Killebrew #220 Are Not #490
A 1968 Mickey Mantle Topps baseball card could mean his individual #280 or the three-player #490. The same distinction applies to Willie Mays and Harmon Killebrew.
| 1968 card | What the collector is buying | Main comparison |
| #280 Mickey Mantle | Individual veteran issue | Other Mantle #280 sales in matching grades |
| #50 Willie Mays | Individual Giants issue | Mays #50 condition and eye appeal |
| #220 Harmon Killebrew | Individual Twins issue | Killebrew #220 sales |
| #490 Super Stars | One card featuring all three | The exact three-player issue, not combined solo prices |
- Player context: Our Mantle card selling research and Willie Mays post-rookie guide explain their broader collecting demand.
Where the Super Stars Card Fits in the 598-Card Set
The 1968 Topps baseball card set includes three memorable combination issues. Each has different players, appeal, and sales history, so a price for one cannot establish another’s value.
- #480 Manager’s Dream: Tony Oliva, Chico Cardenas, and Roberto Clemente.
- #490 Super Stars: Killebrew, Mays, and Mantle.
- #530 Bird Belters: Frank Robinson and Brooks Robinson.
- Series context: #490 falls in the sixth series. Later 1968 numbers may be called high numbers, but that alone does not make this card a short print.
What the Burlap-Style Border Reveals About Condition
The distinctive 1968 Topps baseball card design has a textured, burlap-like frame. It looks forgiving in photographs but can reveal chipping, rough edges, and uneven centering under close inspection.
| Check | What to look for on #490 |
| Centering | Unequal frame width or an image pushed toward one edge |
| Miscut | A visibly slanted cut, especially near the photograph |
| Corners | Softness, bends, and damaged tips |
| Surface | Creases, stains, print marks, or paper loss |
| Reverse | Writing, scuffs, discoloration, or missing paper |
- Handling caution: Photographs can hide defects. Inspect gently under side lighting; never straighten, erase, or attempt to improve the surface.
What 2026 Sales Actually Reveal About #490
1968 Topps baseball card values change dramatically with grade. Actual transactions for #490 provide a much better starting point than a seller’s optimistic listing or an exceptional auction headline.
| Reported sale | Date | Realized price |
| PSA 5 | August 17, 2026 | $291 |
| PSA 8 | October 5, 2026 | $835 |
| PSA 10 | August 28, 2026 | $22,500 |
- Reading the results: These are separate graded copies, not guaranteed prices for raw cards. PSA’s #490 CardFacts and sale records provide grade-specific context.
The PSA 10 Headline Needs One Important Warning
A spectacular sale can make ordinary 1968 Topps baseball cards sound more valuable than they are. PSA recorded only 30 Gem Mint 10 examples of #490 in the population data reviewed.
- Population warning: Grading counts cover submitted copies, not every surviving example. A worn card should never be valued using a Gem Mint sale.
- Compare PSA 3 with PSA 3, not with PSA 10.
- Check whether the card has a qualifier or noticeable eye-appeal difference.
- Include transaction date, buyer’s premium, and venue when comparing results.
The Rest of the 1968 Box Could Matter More
Among the most valuable 1968 Topps baseball cards, the Nolan Ryan and Jerry Koosman rookie #177 and Johnny Bench rookie #247 deserve separate inspection. Neither appears on the Super Stars card.
- Also inspect: Clemente #150, Hank Aaron #110, and Tom Seaver #45. Their condition can outweigh the trio card in a particular box.
- For context: Our 1960s baseball card valuation guide explains rookie demand and later-career stars.
Should You Grade #490 or Preserve the Collection Together?
Before paying a grading fee, compare the 1968 Topps Super Stars #490 as a raw card with realistic graded examples. Authentication may help a questionable copy, but grading does not create better corners.
- Consider grading: A genuine, clean card with strong centering and enough potential upside after fees.
- Consider selling raw: Heavy wear, obvious creases, or costs that consume any expected premium.
- Review the whole group: If #490 came from a near-complete album, assess other stars and rookies before breaking it apart.
- Choose a route: Consult our PSA versus SGC overview and keep, grade, or sell guide before submitting.
A Complete 1968 Set Needs More Than #490
A 1968 Topps baseball card set contains 598 numbered base cards. The Super Stars issue is one of them, while other specialty issues and recognized variations can expand a master collection.
- Record missing numbers: Set value depends on completeness, rookie condition, the quality of #490, and recognized variations.
- Preserve context: Keep the card order and storage details. Our vintage buying criteria include partial sets, stars, and high-grade commons.
- Avoid false totals: Adding retail asking prices for 598 cards rarely produces a realistic collection offer.
North Carolina Collectors Can Review the Story Before Selling
At Baseball Card Roadshows, we offer private North Carolina appraisals for 1968 Topps baseball cards and other vintage collections. Our goal is to explain realistic choices, not promise record auction results.
- Relevant experience: Founder Gary Leavitt has over 40 years of collecting experience and a Certified Fraud Examiner background.
- Local availability: North Carolina appointments include Charlotte, Raleigh-Durham, Greensboro, Asheville, and other communities; confirm your preferred appointment location.
- Bring clear front-and-back photographs of #490 and nearby cards.
- Keep the Mantle, Mays, and rookie cards with the original collection.
- Ask about pre-grading guidance, a collection appraisal, or an optional buying offer.
- No sale required: Learn about appraisals without selling or arrange a private collection review before making a decision.